Showing posts with label Catholic Truth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Catholic Truth. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

In the Spirit of Saint Nicholas and Saint Augustine of Hippo

As Saint Augustine of Hippo said, "It is better to allow the birth of scandal, than to abandon the truth."

So let us, in a spirit of Charity and Muscular Catholicism, confront lies and liars, and (but only metaphorically) knock them down.

Saturday, February 19, 2011

LEFT-FOOTED HERESY? TRUTH, LOVE, LIES

Of mental reservation, lies
I've really had a bucket
-ful. I read long dissertations
On Truth, and think,"Well chuck it!"

When faced with murder, rape, seems we
Must check the Cathechism.
Saints Augustine and Acquinas,
Before we make decision

On whether to choose Life or Truth:
When murder may ensue,
To save an innocent life, I'd lie.
For me, better be true

To family, neighbours, those I love,
Than bow to an abstraction
And make a god of truthfulness.
Better the infraction

Of Truth  (what is it?  Ideas clothed
In speech, blurred in translation),
Than stand aghast, afraid to lie,
While Rachel mourns her Nation.

For what was good for Raphael,
For Rahab, Esau, And Pope
Pius XII will do for me.
Mercy my duty and Hope.

Words are the dress of thoughts, or so
Lord Chesterfield remarked.
Language translated, dress of dress,
Dog-matically barked,

By those who try to confine God
To Truth or Love or Beauty.
He's no abstraction, but Infinite,
Personal.  And our duty

Is to obey, love, follow Him, 
And after Him, love our neighbour,
Not erect doubtful words as gods
And use them to belabour

The brave, who for the Love of God
And neighbour, like serpents, wise
Weaponless, helpless, terrified, struck
With weakness's weapon: lies.


Notes:

1. Yes, "chuck it", with a nod to the shade of Bowdler!

 2. I am aware of the weak, half-rhyme or assonance of Cathechism - decision, and hope to improve on it.

Sunday, December 5, 2010

CHRISTOPHER HITCHENS V. TONY BLAIR: THE GREAT DEBATE

So they debated whether religion is a force for good in the world. Huh!

Are sharks a force for good in the world? As someone who is anything but a 'deep ecologist', I consider sharks, along with crocodiles, leprosy, tornados, HIV and streptococci a force for evil. They sometimes kill people. However, I don't stop believing in them. They manifestly exist. I believe, but I love them not. I wish they could be exterminated, if you can do that to a tornado.

So what does the verdict amount to? If as a Catholic, or Muslim, or whatever, I come to see that religion is a force for what other people do not regard as 'good', do I stop believing? If a deranged Pope ate a Cardinal, would I become an atheist?

Had the debate been about the truth of a particular religion, that would have been interesting, but well beyond the intellctual capabilities of Tony Blair. Those who could have carried it off are all dead. George Weigel maybe?

Your comments are more than welcome.

Saturday, November 13, 2010

WHERE ARE YOU COMING FROM?

Before the last war Peter Drucker heard in Germany a nazi party official explaining to a crowd in the street, "We don't want high bread prices. We don't want low bread prices. We don't want the same bread prices. We want national socialist bread prices."

Mad? Certainly, but for me understandably mad.

A wise African is said to have remarked to a Christian missionary, "How can I hear what you say, when what you are is deafening me?"

Not mad, but perfectly understandable.

St Paul exhorted the early Christians to be submissive to the magistrates, because their authority is ultimately derived from God. (Somebody please give me the reference, because I'm temporarily without a New Testament in English.)

Maybe I'm a leetle bit heretical, but I have never been able to accept what St Paul said here. After all, Jesus described Satan as the prince of this world. I will obey wise and just laws, made by a wise, just, and good government (in a sense acceptable to my Catholic conscience). Laws made by moral aliens are facts, like gravity, to be circumvented, frustrated, subverted, overcome.

If I were to live in a future Caliphate of Europe, I would regard it as a duty to eat pork, drink alcohol, and do anything else I safely could to undermine the government.

As I have already said, I admire devout Muslims, but not their religion.

I have a great affection for Jews I have known, but if I were forced (yes, highly unlikely) to live in a future Hassidic state, I would spend much of my time drinking pork and lobster milk-shakes. And being outrageously Catholic.

Prim parliamentary killjoys in the UK make normal people (like me) want to be drunk as owls and smoke like chimneys.

The UK is not just a secular state - it countenances religions only insofar as it may be a useful tool of control, viz Blair's 'Faith Foundation'. It is in effect anti-religious. Those of a religious persuasion who live under it should, like Hotspur, "cavil at the ninth part of a hair".

His Holiness has called for us Catholics to be a creative minority, and I hope many of us are.

I would add to that, we should be a disruptive minority, and endeavour to make sure that anti-Catholic, anti-life, evil government cannot work.

We should not be following the example of the English Hierarchy in cosying up to those powerful and prestigious interests which are seeking the destruction of the family, childhood innocence, authentic religion (by describing it as culture), and all inconvenient morality.

Thank God I have the good fortune to live in Poland, where abortion is almost non-existent, and both Church and family are strong and resilient. Here I can be that bizarre creature - a patriotic non-Pole. I can comfortably respect the law, police, and judges.

Ultimately, however, I am a citizen of my own skin, owing allegiance only to God, to the Church, to those I love, and to the Truth.

Sunday, July 4, 2010

A Horrible Memory

A few days after being received into the Catholic Church in 1989, I went to Mass, I think on a weekday, at Farm Street. It was the week of Christian Unity.

Father (Professor) Thomas McMahon S.J. (I think) gave the homily, and declared:

"The time will come - certainly in our lifetimes, when there will be no Catholic Church, no denominations. We shall all be together. It will be a new church. Many people will be sad at having to give up much which they love....."

He did not elaborate on what we should have to give up in the credal horse-trading which would clearly precede this amalgamation, nor on whether the new church would be world-wide, or merely a British phenomenon.

My oral memory is very good, but not perfect, and I may have misrepresented the actual words, but certainly not the sense. It was a shock - 30 years deliberating whether to become a Catholic, and now - had I hitched my wagon to a dead horse?

I whizzed into the confessional, but not to confess, and the priest, Father Bermingham, reassured me that nothing was going to change. He was wise old man, like Father John Tracy S.J., to whom I owe my final decision to convert.

I don't know whether Professor McMahon is still alive. If he is, I suppose there is still time for his prediction to be fulfillled. Time for nuancing, lying.

But how, why?

The truth is not negotiable.

The clever money is still on the Pope.

Thursday, May 6, 2010

Errrr what do you mean, exactly

First, a little story, a true one.

A few years ago, when I was working for a homelessness charity in London, a young pregnant client asked me to help her get an abortion.

When I told her that, as a Roman Catholic, I could not help with an abortion, but could suggest charities which could help her with preparing for the baby and finding a flat, she complained to the manager, who told me I could not continue to work for the organization, which was multicultural and valued and promoted all cultures. I was not open to the client’s culture.

I asked her if the organization practised religious discrimination, and reminded her that my application for the job had been supported by a reference from an openly Catholic priest.

She asked me if my anti-abortion stance was part of my “culture”. I replied, “No, part of my religion.” She relaxed at this, and said, ”We value and respect all cultures here, including yours.” Smart move.

And so the conversation ended and I kept my job, on the understanding that my religion was just a part of my “culture”, like enjoying poetry, or alcohol, or jazz, or wearing a tie - quite acceptable as a lifestyle choice, as long as it poses no threat to the social cohesion demanded by governments from the disparate people they try to control.

Culture and religion are not the same. For seriously religious people, their coreligionist are their tribe, their nation. Whoever shares my religion, whatever her or his ethnicity, colour, social class, personal hygiene, taste in music, shirts, or food, is someone I can understand: a sister or a brother.

The creation of a cohesive, easily malleable group of people is the aim of governments. To reach this goal, the divisive stony Decalogue of monotheistic religion must give way to the inclusive soggy ukase of the nanny state, which is, when challenged, of adamantine hardness.

Governmental insistence on “diversity” is interesting, because it is self-contradictory. The diversity of a Muslim, or a Catholic does not accept the diversity of someone who practises homosexual sex. The diversity of a practicing homosexual does not accept the diversity of a someone who states that such acts are against the natural law. Clearly diversity must pertain only to the cultural, not ethical, because ethical diversity raises too many problems and must therefore be eliminated.

So what is the solution for those in authority?


Among the methods used to erode ethical or religious diversity is ambiguity or imprecision. Nothing is right or wrong, but simply acceptable or unacceptable – but to whom? They word “culture” is used to cover religion, morality, dress, the arts, food – the list is long. This recourse to ambiguity is used not only by civil governments, but sometimes also by religious authorities. The ARCIC documents are an example. The old I.C.E.L. translation of the Mass, for example, used the phrase (of the bread before consecration) “it will become for us the Body of Christ”.

What do these words mean? Does “for us” mean “for our sake”, as in “my parents did a lot for me?”, or “in our opinion”, as in “for me, music is the greatest of the arts”. Is It the Body of Christ, only for us, not for everyone? There is no ambiguity in the Latin, but I am not so sure that there was no vagueness in the minds of the translators.

The books used twenty years ago in the preparation of my children for first Holy Communion avoided the divisive doctrine of Transubstantiation altogether. My parish priest in England when I asked him about this told me that my understanding of the Sacrament was too crude. “We have moved forward from all that”. Another weasel phrase – why do we always move forward, never sideways or backwards? Is theology also subject to Darwinian evolution, so that later is always better?

And what have we moved forward from? From plain speaking to anodyne obfuscation.

VERITAS IN CARITATE - truth in charity - is a fine motto. Truth curtailed by a desire to be tactful, or accepted, is not so fine. If no one knows what anyone means, no reasonable discourse is possible. Terms cannot be defined and no one can agree or disagree.

Truth perishes.