The UCL brouhaha has brought out Catholic Voices in fine form. I am indebted to That the Bones You Have Crushed May Thrill for his latest three posts on this matter.
Their first attempt to explain Catholic attitudes, episcopal and lay, to ending abortion, England and Wales was:
1 'But in reality, Catholics on campus have nothing to fear. The motion contains no definition of "pro-choice"; if it means simply someone who accepts that abortion should be legal, most Catholics -- including the bishops of England and Wales, who advocate incremental restrictions, but not yet a total ban -- would fit that description.'
Really?
Their second go was as follows:
2 The motion contains no definition of "pro-choice"; if it means simply someone who accepts that abortion cannot be prohibited immediately, most informed Catholics -- including the bishops of England and Wales, who advocate incremental restrictions, but not yet a total ban -- would fit that description.'
And their third attempt to explain what they mean is here:
3 'But in reality, Catholics on campus have nothing to fear. The motion's definition of pro-choice ideology is so narrow and extreme, and its actions so brow-beating and authoritarian, that it will show informed pro-lifers who accept that abortion cannot be prohibited immediately -- including the bishops of England and Wales, who advocate incremental restrictions, but realise that a total ban is currently impossible to achieve -- to be the true advocates of moderate, rational and humane principle.'
I understand that "Catholic Voices" as a group offer training to aspiring Catholic apologists, and are said to be quite selective in their choice of speakers and writers.
You could have fooled me.
QUIS CUSTODET IPSOS CUSTODES?
Rock Bottom, Or: Meet Dalai Leo, Pope Poncho 2.0
-
It’s not only the childishness. The superficiality. The attention whoring.
It’s the utter vulgarity. It’s wearing flip-flops when you visit Ipanema as
a po...
3 days ago