Showing posts with label syncretism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label syncretism. Show all posts

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Syncretism 2

All religions contain some element or elements of truth, a fact which I would not wish to deny, but:

(1) Is it reasonable for a Catholic to suppose that the Holy Spirit has revealed to other religions or to sects truths which have not being made available to, or have been repudiated by, the Catholic Church?

If so, the pretensions of the Catholic Church seem, to this humble and ignorant Left-footer, to be just pretensions.

If not, why read the scriptures of other religions or sects except with the purpose of converting their adherents. Or why read, quote, or endorse protestant theology?

(2) Can a Catholic learn anything of spiritual value, from other religions?

If so, what?

(3) Can a Catholic learn anything of value from the practitioners of other religions?

Well yes. There are good and wise people outside the Catholic Church.To give examples, from Muslims we can learn the worth of zeal, fasting, pilgrimage, and prayer, and from Jews, reverence, tradition, and scrupulousness (and more).

But the Catholic Church is as right as it is possible to be in matters of Faith.

Anything which differs or diverges is WRONG.

SYNCRETINISM (SIC)!

So Pope John-Paul II  is to be beatified. He was a great, good, and holy man, and I rejoice.

But what are we to make of the shenanigans at Assisi? Of a heathen statue on the altar? Of the later Koran-kissing, if true as reported?

Ecumenical? Charitable? Universalist? Ill-advised? Foolish? Syncretist?

Sometimes some people, including me, were frightened.