Sunday, December 19, 2010

IS THERE A FUTURE?

My answer to the question is, "Not yet."

Let me start by stating the obvious - I am no philosopher, and I am not about to say anything profound, startling, or new.

A long time ago I read most of Plato, Aristotle, and, of course, the Dialogues of their fountainhead, Socrates.

The biggest surprise for me was reading the amazing dialogue between Chanticlere and Pertelote, cock and hen, in Chaucers Nun's Priest's Tale. Their subject, predestination, still grips and worries me.

The argument put forward by Chanticlere, as I remember it, is this: If God is omnipotent and omniscient, then He must know the future.

If He knows the future, then the future is already determined.

If the future is already predetermined, then we have no freedom of action, no free-will.

To extrapolate beyond Chaucer, if we have no free-will, we cannot choose between Heaven or Hell.

Divine Justice is therefore unjust.

About twenty three years ago, when I was struggling with Catholicism, I read a book whose title I forget, by a Jesuit Chaplain (of Eton College, but I don't hold that against him - I forget his name too).

It was a series of meditations on the life of Saint Francis Xavier, who intended to convert China, and of course died before he had even started. One remark sticks in my mind.

"God sees us, not as we are, but as we are becoming."

Of course, because God knows our intentions.

I accept three spatial dimensions, but the fourth, time, is fundamentally different. We can travel in three dimensions, exist in them, measure them, but in time, we can travel only forward. It is not, I think, a dimension in the same sense as the others.

The future does not yet exist. Future souls may indeed exist - that is beyond me, but the future has no existence - yet.

How can God know what does not exist? It's reminiscent of silly questions such as: 'Can God make a stone so heavy that He cannot lift it?'
or 'Can God create a more powerful god than Himself?' Whether the answer is 'yes' or 'no', the questioner will claim to have proved that God is not omnipotent.

I would suggest that God cannot know what is not, because such a possibility is a nonsense.

Your views, please.

Saturday, December 18, 2010

LABELS ARE LAZY - OR WORSE

I've been thinking more about the way labeling people or putting them in boxes, is destructive of both useful thinking and charity towards one's fellow man.

As Paul Mallinder commented on an earlier post, "we just label people when our reason isn't up to the game."

Label-stickers are lazy, or stupid, or vindictive, or dishonest, or I know not what. They dodge the issue of engaging people with whom they disagree, and just dismiss them.

For example, how about 'anti-Semite'? What do the users of this label mean, if not anti-Jew or anti-Israel? A true anti-Semite must also be anti-Arab and anti-Maltese, as both Arabs and Maltese are at least partly Semitic, and both speak Semitic languages. Speak plainly and use 'anti-Jewish' or 'anti-Israel', depending on what you mean. To engage the people is to engage the issues.

'Nazi' is applied indiscriminately to racists. However, under the prussian Bismarck, Adalbert Falk's falk laws expelled Catholic Religious (See Hopkins's "The Wreck of the Deutschland"). Further legislation deprived Poles of the right to speak Polish in school, sell their homes to other Poles, and more. The aim was to eliminate Polishness. IN 1900!

Racist? Very.

Anti-Jewish? No anti-Słowenski.

Nazi? Not under Bismarck, but later.

One more example, ridiculous, horrible, but true.

I had been in Poland about a week when a German, about 30 years old, asked me what I thought of Poles. I replied that I had not had time to form an impression.

So he told me. He said that the Poles were dirty, lazy, ignorant, and poor. Their food was unhealthy and their roads terrible.

He then said that the word Slav is derived from slave, because the Slavonic people exist to serve the teutonic races.

I could have labeled him 'ignorant nazi scumbag', but I didn't (tee hee!). Oh, I wanted to.

I was kind and explained that the Słowenik word which is known as Slav is cognate with Sławny = famous. The word 'slave' is derived from Slav, not vice-versa. I did not label him, but I wanted to kill him.

I then told him about the post WW2 Morgenthau plan, and its vision, thwarted by Roosevelt, of the permanent partition of Germany and its reduction to an agricultural economy.

I ended by telling him what I thought about his country's history.

As to a worthy label? Maybe 'evil idiot'.

He's Back.

Unfortunately.
I have evicted him from here, and if anyone is so inclined, they may read his ramblings at bishopsmirk.blogspot.com

Torquemada Shrooms released - New Twist in Glastonbury Mystery

Shrooms, arrested on a charge of murder and hate crime after he apparently ran over Smirk, a local preacher, with his steam-roller, has been released without charge, according to a Somerset police spokesman.

This follows forensic tests on the remains found outside Smirk's flat, which proved to be from a huge roast pig.

Shrooms's daughter, Muriel, who allegedly recently took out a very large life assurance policy on the missing Smirk, is helping police with their inquiries.

Thursday, December 16, 2010

Hilarious Accident in Glastonbury

It is without any particular regret that I report the demise of 'Bishop' Bogus Smirk.

His common-law wife, Muriel Shrooms, Mu for short, a character well-known in the Glastonbury community, reports that after eating a huge psilocybin and 'herb' omelette she had prepared for him, he rushed to the window of their shared ground floor flat, and with a cry of "Shabbaddabbada", threw himself through the glass to the street below.

As the fall was a matter of only eighteen inches, no tragedy could have been foreseen. However, a passing steamroller swerved to avoid a sparrow in the road, skidded, and ran over the unfortunate man.

It may be of some consolation to him, wherever he is, that he was physically as widely spread on the surface of the road as he had hoped his church and his literary fame would be in the world beyond the Somerset town where he lived.

If the public feel so inclined, they may leave their condolences in the comment box.

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

A NEW PRAISE SONG FROM BISHOP SMIRK (at least I think that's what it is)

Hi! It's Smirkie, the Mugwumpist.

Us poets depend so much on inspiration, don't you agree? I been trying to write a cool praise song for our Winter Season Praise Service. Trying for a week! Then I went up the Tor for some serious puffing (heh!), and the good weed brought me this.

Cool?

But I can't think of a good title - maybe "YEAH!" - can anyone help? But don't get snide - be positive! And don't get all technical about tenses. "When the creed and the colour and the name WON'T matter WERE you there?" is ok - everybody loves singing it.


I saw a man sitting by a tree.
Yeah, I saw a man sitting by a tree.
He's sitting by a tree
And that man is you and me!
I saw a man sitting by a tree.

I saw a man looking at a rope.
Yeah, I saw a man looking at a rope.
He's looking at that rope
Cuz he ain't got any hope.
I saw a man looking at a rope.

I saw a man standing on a chair
Yeah, I saw a man standing on a chair
He's standing on a chair
And he's reaching in the air.
I saw a man standing on a chair.

I saw a man tying rope to bough
Yeah, I saw a man tying rope to bough
He's tying rope to bough,
And I think he's ready now.
I saw a man tying rope to bough.

I saw a man kicking at a chair
Yeah, I saw a man kicking at a chair.
He's kicking at the chair
Now he's swinging in the air
I saw a man swinging in the air.

I saw a man hanging from a tree
Yeah, I saw a man hanging from a tree
He's hanging from a tree
And that man is you and me
I saw a man hanging from a tree.


Why was that man hanging in a tree?
Because of society's cruelty!
So let's go into the street,
Smile at people that we meet,
And show them just how happy they can be!


More to come! YAY, as we say.

This Instrument Kills Fascists

When Woody Guthrie went on tour after the last war, his guitar was decorated with the words - "This instrument kills fascists".

How many did it kill during the war I wonder?

I don't much like political 'folk' singers. "Killing Kruger with your mouth"?

Huh!

IMPERIALIST FASCIST STOOGE MACMILLAN

When I was about 17, I dearly wanted to be a communist. I read Marx's 'Capital', in translation, of course, and found it often heady and poetic.

Then I tuned into Radio Moscow, which was in English, and heard a Russian woman reading the news. Russian, like Polish, is a beautiful, very musical languge, but both Russians and Poles speak English without much intonation or emotion, so that to us they sound very cold.

The woman's words stick with me: "The imperialist fascist stooge, Macmillan, speaking yesterday in the so-called British Parliament, said that...."

That was enough. No more communism for me.

Why is it so tempting to insult the opposition or enemy? Labels like 'fascist', 'nazi', 'liberal', are bandied about, often with little regard for their historical significance, as though they were potent weapons for defeating opponents. As Kipling wrote over 100 years ago:

When you've shouted, "Rule Britannia!" when you've sung, "God Save the Queen",
When you've finished killing Kruger with your mouth."

what have you achieved? Perhaps very little. As with swearing, so with verbal abuse, using the currency debases it. The lewd words or insults progressively fail to satisfy, and reveal their own impotence and the user's. If you spend much time on Twitter, and I spend less than I used to, you will soon become bored with displays of bad-mouthing.

As an art form, it soon palls.

St John the Baptist did it, and so did St Thomas More, but much more creatively, and therefore more tellingly. There was poetry and passion in their invective. They were wise and good men, Saints, and their language was chosen to tell the truth, inspire their supporters, denigrate the enemy, and demolish his arguments.

But it is hard to see what purpose is served by merely insulting opponents, whether they be 'Taliban' Catholics, liberal 'fascists', or any other hated group, without actually pointing out where they are wrong.

Does doing so advance the cause, whatever it may be?
Rather, it is off-putting to many who might otherwise be inclined to listen to us. See above.

Does it hurt or demoralise the enemy?
Only clever satire can do that, not name-calling..

Does it rally and motivate our supporters and make them feel better?
Probably yes, if they are people of not very subtle perceptions.

Does it make us feel better?
Yes, of course. Watch a little dog behind its garden gate, go into yappping frenzy when a big dog, on a lead, has safely gone past.

Does it betray the fact that we feel weak, impotent, and on the losing side of a battle?
I fear so.

Let us by, all means, trash, rout, demoralise, destroy the enemy and his credibility, but, like G. K. Chesterton (who never sank to insulting even his arch enemies) let us do so with meticulous reasoning, wit, and truth. It was the rather risible F. E. Smith who dismissed Chesterton as an 'obese mountebank', as though his bulk invalidated his polemic.

Do we go to F.E. Smith for wisdom? I rather think not.

Saturday, December 11, 2010

A THING RABBIT KNOWS

If you enjoy A.A. Milne's "Winnie The Pooh" and "The House At Pooh Corner" (not the cartoon versions) as much as I do, you may remember the sad chapter near the end of the second book where Christopher Robin is learning his alphabet and 'twy stimes' table, and is obviously going off to school.

Eeyore, the gloomy donkey, thinks he will learn the alpahbet too, and makes an "A" out of sticks, and asks Rabbit, the perennial busybody, what it is.

Rabbit replies, "An A, but not a very good one."

Poor Eeyore, cut to the quick, jumps on the sticks, saying "A, a thing Rabbit knows?"

Ever felt like that? I have.

It is very unpleasant (and hard to accept) when someone I don't like, who is a bit of a know-all, gets it right, and in a smarty-pants kind of way.

"How can I hear what you say, when what you are is deafening me?" as an African is said to have asked a European missionary.

We must always be careful - no, I must - to be sure that when we reject an idea, we are not rejecting it simply out of dislike or contempt for, or a grievance against, the author of that idea.

For example:

I don't like Richard Dawkins's face. I don't like clever-head atheists. If he told me the time I would want a second opinion: not reasonable.

Likewise Tony Blair: when he was received into the Catholic Church, I was annoyed. When he proved to be a dissenting Catholic, I was, shamefully, just a little gruntled.

The conflict between the Greek leaders Aristides, nicknamed 'The Just" and Themistocles ended in the ostracism of Aristides, at a date variously given between 485 BC and 482 BC. It is said that an illiterate voter, who did not know Aristides, came up to him, and giving him his voting sherd, desired him to write upon it the name of Aristides. The latter asked if Aristides had wronged him.

"No," was the reply, "and I do not even know him, but it irritates me to hear him everywhere called the just."

I am sure I would have liked Aristides and not wished for his ostracism, but even so, that illiterate was, I am ashamed to say, "mon semblable, mon frere".

Wednesday, December 8, 2010

Defamation

A purely academic question, and just out of interest, would it amount to actionable libel or slander in the U.K. to write or say that someone was homosexual or a practising homosexual if they were not?

I have absolutely no intention of putting the answer to the test.