My answer to the question is, "Not yet."
Let me start by stating the obvious - I am no philosopher, and I am not about to say anything profound, startling, or new.
A long time ago I read most of Plato, Aristotle, and, of course, the Dialogues of their fountainhead, Socrates.
The biggest surprise for me was reading the amazing dialogue between Chanticlere and Pertelote, cock and hen, in Chaucers Nun's Priest's Tale. Their subject, predestination, still grips and worries me.
The argument put forward by Chanticlere, as I remember it, is this: If God is omnipotent and omniscient, then He must know the future.
If He knows the future, then the future is already determined.
If the future is already predetermined, then we have no freedom of action, no free-will.
To extrapolate beyond Chaucer, if we have no free-will, we cannot choose between Heaven or Hell.
Divine Justice is therefore unjust.
About twenty three years ago, when I was struggling with Catholicism, I read a book whose title I forget, by a Jesuit Chaplain (of Eton College, but I don't hold that against him - I forget his name too).
It was a series of meditations on the life of Saint Francis Xavier, who intended to convert China, and of course died before he had even started. One remark sticks in my mind.
"God sees us, not as we are, but as we are becoming."
Of course, because God knows our intentions.
I accept three spatial dimensions, but the fourth, time, is fundamentally different. We can travel in three dimensions, exist in them, measure them, but in time, we can travel only forward. It is not, I think, a dimension in the same sense as the others.
The future does not yet exist. Future souls may indeed exist - that is beyond me, but the future has no existence - yet.
How can God know what does not exist? It's reminiscent of silly questions such as: 'Can God make a stone so heavy that He cannot lift it?'
or 'Can God create a more powerful god than Himself?' Whether the answer is 'yes' or 'no', the questioner will claim to have proved that God is not omnipotent.
I would suggest that God cannot know what is not, because such a possibility is a nonsense.
Your views, please.
Rock Bottom, Or: Meet Dalai Leo, Pope Poncho 2.0
-
It’s not only the childishness. The superficiality. The attention whoring.
It’s the utter vulgarity. It’s wearing flip-flops when you visit Ipanema as
a po...
3 days ago