Showing posts with label Stalin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stalin. Show all posts

Thursday, January 10, 2013

Stalin Joke No. 5 - not nice

It is 1944, and a soviet general has been discussing his campaign with Stalin. As he walks away from the meeting, a guard in the corridor hears him mutter, "Idiot!" 

He marches into Stalin's office and reports what he has heard. Stalin thanks him, orders him to wait in the office, and rings the guard at the gate with instructions to escort the general back. The general enters, and Stalin asks him, "Who were you referring to as an idiot?"

"Hitler, of course."

Stalin turns to the guard. "And who did you think he was referring to?"

Tuesday, August 21, 2012

The Pen Mightier than the Sword? Tell that to the Maccabees - Smite, Smote, Smitten

As a child, I loved the Old Testament much more than the New, and my favourite passages all involved the Jews smiting the unbeliever.

I am not so sure that the pen is mightier than the sword. Think what horrors might never have been if Marx had been bumped off by a footpad, or Hitler or Stalin fallen to an enemy bullet.

It seems that modern philosophical, moral, ethical, and political thought assumes rational discourse between rational beings. This assumption often proves false because:

  1. Either one, or neither of the beings is rational. I heard a woman walking and emptying  her dog on Sunday morning in the local churchyard, say to it, "Hurry up! The bell's ringing. People will be here soon." The dog appeared to understand, and no doubt its owner thought it did. Dialogue with those who support abortion is often not very different. St Nicholas's dispute with Arius is an example.
  2. The conversation, spoken or written is between people who have differing, or no, moral or religious beliefs. Sometimes they have a different agenda, which may overide those beliefs.
  3. Their is a lack of good will in one or both of the parties.
  4. There is a linguistic problem,  because their understanding of the meaning and import of words diverges.
  5. There is a linguistic problem,  because at least one of them is  deforming the meaning of, or nuancing, language.
  6.  There are certainly more reasons for failure of jaw-jaw as opposed to war-war.

Thinking with great affection, as I often do, of David, King Alfred, the Crusades, Joan of Arc, Don John of Austria, King Jan Sobieski, the fights for Irish, Polish, and Scottish Independence, I am convinced of one thing. As  Clausewitz wrote:

War is not different from diplomacy. It is diplomacy conducted by other means. We see, therefore, that War is not merely a political act, but also a real political instrument, a continuation of political commerce, a carrying out of the same by other means. All beyond this which is strictly peculiar to War relates merely to the peculiar nature of the means which it uses. That the tendencies and views of policy shall not be incompatible with these means, the Art of War in general and the Commander in each particular case may demand, and this claim is truly not a trifling one. But however powerfully this may react on political views in particular cases, still it must always be regarded as only a modification of them; for the political view is the object, War is the means, and the means must always include the object in our conception.

When a nation, creed, or individual is faced by the untruthful, the irrational, the cruel, the opressive, or the murderous, reasonable argument is powerless and fails, and diplomacy should perhaps be continued, but by other means. After all, David, Alfred (sometimes), Don John, and King Jan won.

As the abominable cromwell of evil memory said, "Put your trust in God; but mind to keep your powder dry."


Monday, October 11, 2010

Stalin Joke No 4

Early on a beautiful summer morning Stalin gets out of bed, goes to the window, and draws the curtains back.

The Sun is shining, and, to Stalin's surprise, says, "Good morning, Comrade Stalin."

"Good morning," replies Stalin, wondering about the strength and quality of the previous night's vodka.

In the afternoon, taking a break from his work, Stalin goes into the garden. The Sun again greets him, "Good afternoon, Comrade Stalin, Great Teacher!"

"Good afternoon, and thank you," replies Stalin.

In the evening, at the end of a glorious day, Stalin is again in the garden and looks up at the setting Sun. "Good evening, he says, tentatively.

"Sod off, you stupid commie bastard!" replies the Sun.

"Why are you so rude now, when you were so polite before?" asks Stalin.

"Ha! Ha! I'm in the West now."

Thursday, September 2, 2010

Stalin Joke 2

The great Thinker and Teacher receives a delegation of Georgians in his office, and when they have gone, can't find his pipe.

He immediately telephones Beria. "See if one of them has taken my pipe."

A minute later, he finds his pipe on the windowsill. He telephones Beria, "It's all right. I've found it."

"Too late, Josef Vissarionovich."

"What do you mean, Lavrentiy Pavlovich, too late?"

"Half of them have confessed, and been liquidated. The other half unfortunately died under interrogation."

Stalin chuckles and fills his pipe.

Wednesday, September 1, 2010

Stalin Joke 1

Jokes about Stalin abound, all bitterly cynical. Humour was of course an important safety valve for people in the Warsaw Pact countries.

It's Stalin's birthday in 1950, and the Great Teacher is making a speech to a vast audience of commisaars etc.

About three hours into his oration, someone in the audience sneezes.

Stalin stops, hands on hips, and asks mildly, "Who sneezed?"

Silence.

Again he asks, "Who sneezed?"

Again silence.

"Guards," he says gently, "shoot the front row."

The guards obey, and the front row slumps to the floor.

"Again I ask who sneezed?"

Again silence. "Guards, shoot the back row."

They obey.

Then a man in the middle stands up. "It was I who sneezed, Comrade Stalin."

Stalin beams. "Bless you!"

Thursday, June 10, 2010

Thank You Poland

"Why don't the British like us?" I often have to try to answer that question here in Poland, and the answer tends to be along these lines:

The English, ever since the Great Fraud of Henry VIII have had an aversion to Catholics

They have an aversion to foreigners.

They know little geography and less history. (Duh? Where is Poland?) They distrust well-educated people (envy?). By contrast, my postman here in Poland, remarked, when I said I would not be returning to England, "As Epicurus said, 'You can't step twice into the same river'."

Good fortune has rendered the Briish devoid of gratitude.

Today, a sympathetic Daily Telegraph blog, by Daniel Hannan, followed by the usual duck-speaking comment-writers, has moved me to try and explain a few facts about Poland.

From the 1780s to 1918, Poland as an independent nation did not exist. Poland did not appear in the ancient atlases we still used at school in the 1950s. Partitioned between Russia, Prussia, and Austria-Hungary, it was, as Paderewski remarked, "Not so much a country as a state of mind".

The effects of the partitioning were not uniform. The Astro-Hungarian occupation was mainly benign, with employment and education open to imperial subjects. The Russian presence varied from tolerable to barbaric. The Prussian occupation, particularly after the passing of the Falk laws, was oppressive. The Polish language was proscribed in schools, and children who used it were flogged. By the beginning of the 20th century, a Pole could sell his house only to a German national.

Poland became independent in 1918. In 1920 Poland repelled a U.S.S.R invasion at the battle of the Vistula. The invasion, Stalin's brainchild, was intended to pass through Poland to Germany, foment revolution in Germany, and help German communists install a Marxist state. Stalin's hope was that the whole of western Europe would fall to communism.

Perhaps Europeans should be thanking Poland, the nation whose earlier intervention in 1683, led by King Jan Sobieski's army, at the battle of Vienna may well have saved Europe from being overrun by the Ottoman Empire. Sharia, anyone?

In the 2nd World War, Germany killed 20% of the Polish population, half of them Jews. The U.S.S.R. murdered 22,000 at Katyń. The Poles were doughty pilots in the Battle of Britain, killing more Germans per pilot than their British counterparts, using fewer mechanics, and losing fewer pilots and planes. Air Marshal Dowding said at the time, that it was not possible to say that without the Poles, the Battle of Britain would have been won by the U.K.

But Poland was sneered at by the British press, intrigued against by the civil service, the Curzon Line was secretly moved westward by the Polish traitor Lewis Namier, after he became a British citizen and a civil servant. Namier had access to the map, and passed his alteration to Stalin, so that Poland lost the historic city of Lwów (now Lviv) to the U.S.S.R. At Yalta, Stalin produced the map, asked if Churchill and Roosevelt agreed to the Curzon line, and when they assented, compensated the Poles with a chunk of Germany.

Snubbed by Thatcher over Katyń, emerging unbroken after 44 years of communism, Poland is now the butt of jokes, sneers, and smears, and was even accused last year by an intemperate Times columnist of celebrating Easter before the last war by burning Jews alive in their synagogues. The same learned and well-informed columnist thought it an insult to call Poles "Polacks". A Polish man is a Polak, and a Polish woman a Polka, but I doubt if he will read this.

So, thank you, Poles and Poland, that I am alive, have a family, am not a subject of the third reich, or a Muslim.

And thank you, Mary Queen of Poland, who over the centuries have imbued with such strength this remarkable nation.